Not sure about anyone else, but Ive had nothing but problems with Athearn electrical pickup causing problems. I eliminated 95% of it by soldering the pickup wires directly to the metal plates the axle bushings ride on. Seems to have done the trick.
I bought a brand new GP40 on e-bay for $40 that someone put a DCC decoder in, hooked to the 9 pin plug and couldn't get to work. I pulled the decoder and plugged in an LM-2. No joy. Wired it like I said to the sideframes and it's the best running 4 axle I own. Still using the factory light board too, but soldered the connections. Just my 2c