General > General Discussion
Layout control panels
Alan:
--- Quote from: G8B4Life on July 26, 2020, 11:20:10 AM ---BTW, the JST headers are available in way cooler colours than white too but you'd probably have a hard time finding them outside of the JST online shop.
- Tim
--- End quote ---
Darn you Tim. Couldn't stop thinking about your comment on connector colors. Sure enough, JST offers 9 colors. Would have been perfect to color code the panel connectors as I would have needed 8 colors at most. I guess it falls into the "if I had it to do over" category.
--- Quote from: emd_16645 on July 29, 2020, 08:15:56 AM ---Alan, I think you need to brush up on your Red Green episodes. Your mobile work station didn't have a scrap of duct tape on it. ;D
--- End quote ---
Oops. No Possum Lodge invitation for me. :-[
trainman605:
I'm and older guy and grew up with control panels, but with todays control system DCC, RailPro, etc. why would you want to go back in time 20 years. I guess it you always ran your trains that way, which at one time was the only way to operate a large layout and it's still your choice of operating system today, them go for it. These control panels that are shown in the above post are really nice and done very well, I wouldn't want to take anything away from them, so If that your way of running trains them that's the system you should use. I model in HOn3 and the D&RGW narrow gauge operated there trains the old fashion way, my layout works the same way. My new layout in G scale is running RailPro, no wiring, no track to clean, I guess RailPro is taking all the fun out of running trains, NOT.
trainman
Alan:
--- Quote from: trainman605 on October 21, 2020, 10:42:09 AM ---I'm and older guy and grew up with control panels, but with todays control system DCC, RailPro, etc. why would you want to go back in time 20 years. I guess it you always ran your trains that way, which at one time was the only way to operate a large layout and it's still your choice of operating system today, them go for it. These control panels that are shown in the above post are really nice and done very well, I wouldn't want to take anything away from them, so If that your way of running trains them that's the system you should use. I model in HOn3 and the D&RGW narrow gauge operated there trains the old fashion way, my layout works the same way. My new layout in G scale is running RailPro, no wiring, no track to clean, I guess RailPro is taking all the fun out of running trains, NOT.
trainman
--- End quote ---
Because I greatly enjoy making things versus buying and plugging things in. If I had sufficient skills I would have built my own control system rather than buying RailPro. Also, not a fan of pecking on a little screen. Imagine how many screen taps it would take to work a yard. You would spend more time interacting with the screen than switching cars. That's not for me. The HC is my loco control stand, nothing more.
William Brillinger:
--- Quote ---Imagine how many screen taps it would take to work a yard.
--- End quote ---
IMO that is not the engineers job either. I prefer hand thrown switches, but if motors are your choice, fascia mounted controls make the best sense to me. Great looking Panels Alan!
G8B4Life:
Yep, there's more to trains than just the locomotive and wagons behind it. One of my rail interests is safeworking so my plan, if I'm ever lucky enough to have a large layout, is to have a proper mechanical interlocking machine to control the station / yard. I have most of the plans for the parts and for the most part I can read a locking sketch (plan of the interlocking) though I do get lost quite easily the larger the interlocking sketch gets. However that sort of layout is all a pipe dream; space for any size layout is zero these days :'(
Control panels like Alans I wouldn't say are "back in time 20 years", Alans panels control only the points (switches), a 20 year old panel would likely control more than just that (track on/off, polarity, cabs etc). Also interlocking as panels still exist to this day so we could just think of Alans panels as interlocking machines... without signals, or actual interlocking.
--- Quote from: William Brillinger on October 21, 2020, 11:46:16 AM ---
--- Quote ---Imagine how many screen taps it would take to work a yard.
--- End quote ---
IMO that is not the engineers job either.
--- End quote ---
Not a yard but it's certainly prototypical. We had (still have?) several installations along a couple of lines where the points (and signals) of the passing loops were activated by radio (DTMF I think) signals. Punch the code for the main or passing loop into the transmitter to change the points / clear the signal, all while on the run.
- Tim
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version