Need for transient voltage-suppressing diodes?

[faithie999]

there is an article in the April 22 edition of MRH about the use of transient voltage-suppressing diodes across DCC motor leads to protect them from failure due to short circuits.
https://online.fliphtml5.com/buups/uzme/index.html#p=49

The author installed SMBJ16CA-13-F across the motor output of a DCC decoder. 

Is there anything inherent in the RP module vs a DCC module that would make this unnecessary?

if they would be beneficial, I would use the 18V version rather than the 16V version the author used on his 13V-powered track.  (ebay) quantity of 100 from china incl shipping is just under $8.00.

thanks

Ken

[G8B4Life]

I think the only way we'll know the answer to this is if Ring provides it,  While I've had the cover off on LM-2S's and LM-3S's (the label adhesive did hold up against the weather here once!) I doubt I could identify a TVS diode just by looking at it. It would be a good answer to know though, RP modules are expensive and anything that one can do to protect them is a good idea.

- Tim